Monthly Archives: August 2014

Awakening Revealed In Few Words

By: David Xi-Ken Astor, Sensei

A monk ask, “What is liberation?”
Shitou replied, “Who has bond you?”
Another monk asked, “What is the Pure Land?”
Shitou said, “Who has polluted you?”
Another monk asked, “What is nirvana?”
Shitou said, “Who has given you birth and death?”

The great Chinese Zen Master, Shitou Xiqian, who lived in the eighth century was a key figure in the development of Ch’an Buddhism. Three of the five traditional schools of Chinese Zen can trace their lineage through his disciples down to the present day, including my own. Shitou taught that “what meets the eye is the Way” A very pragmatic worldview, and one that hints at the influence the Tao had on Buddhist thought and practice in his day.

Master Shitou is said to have had a great awakening while studying the Zhao Lun (A classic text of commentaries on the sutras). In that work he encountered a passage that said, “The one who realized that the myriad things are one’s own self is no different from the sages.” This realization inspired Shitou to write a number of verses, each more refined and elegant than the last as he worked to broaden his state of enlightenment further. Finally he choose just fifteen Chinese characters to represent the awakened wisdom of a mind free of distortion. In English it takes twenty two words to translate:
Each sense and every field
Interact and do not interact;
When interacting, they also merge —
Otherwise, they remain in their own states.

It is not my intent here to provide a full commentary of this verse. But I will give a broad hint as to how to begin to understand this simple, but very deep wisdom gained over many years of contemplation. Consider “each sense” as meaning a gate, entrance or even an exit point. The phrase “every field” means all-encompassing objects or things outside of ourselves, especially the sense organ of mind. That sense, while we can not touch, see hear, smell, or taste it, it can be imagined. Abstract concepts can be objects of mind. While we can not perceive these things, we can awaken to their reality. The sense organs and their objects are the totality of our lives, and when we learn to coordinate their inputs plus the exquisite functions of mind we can grasp the meaning of “emptiness.”

With this in mind, work to understand each word in this verse as an individual piece in the awakening puzzle and with their separate meanings established, fit them together, and in so doing you will see their individual forms disappear, and an awakened view of all reality emerge.

3 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

The Nature Of Dana: Generosity In Action

By: David Xi-Ken Astor, Sensei

The nature of dana, generosity or giving, relates directly to hearing and responding to one’s spiritual calling. In Master Dogen’s ‘Shobogenzo’, two chapters address dana in different ways. The first talk is entitled “Establishment of the Bodhi Mind” and was directed to the laity, and the second is called “Establishment of the Will to the Supreme” which Dogen addressed to the temple monks. These talks were given on the same day about six hours apart we are told, just after Dogen entered his new monastic home in the mountains.

The first instruction was given to the laity as a lesson on generosity of life as it is. He was imploring those who were donating money or labor to the temple, to continue to do so. An age old challenge that continues to haunt Buddhist teachers even today. A little time later, he offered a talk to the monastics in his newly established monastery, but this time focusing on impermanence, the absolutely fleeting nature of life. He beseeched the monastics to give their life away to others, to not get lost in zazen and the solitary practice of realizing themselves before taking care of all beings, including those he had addressed six hours earlier. These two teachings, different in perspective but focused on the same subject, takes dana as the act of contributing to the Sangha’s upkeep and highlights its place in a compassionate practice. The human emotion of compassion is developed when you give selflessly. Likewise, when one receives they are given an opportunity for experiencing feelings of compassion.

Dogen was a master strategist as well as a brilliant dharma teacher as his written works in our possession today reflects. His wonderful teaching reveals dana within a beautiful, circular path, flowing in both directions among the laity and the monastics. Utterly and forever different, each giving to the other. The recognition of the inter-being of self and other. The social-self in action. Through these two we create a wonderful interplay of dana, of exchange, of one hand supporting the other and the other supporting the first to the point that it is not clear which is giving and which is receiving. That is when we enter into the heart of ‘dana paramita,’ the perfection of selfless giving. The term ‘dana’ when used alone is referencing our actions toward upkeep of something we highly value. The term ‘dana paramita’ encompasses all acts of generosity, including those of supporting directly the transmission of the dharma. Continue reading

3 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

Intimacy With Unity Of All Things

By: David Xi-Ken Astor, Sensei

 In a wonderful Tibetan Buddhist story, a man tells his friend about an extraordinary spiritual teacher he has met. Although this friend is curious about this teacher, he is also somewhat skeptical, so he decides to seek out this holy man and put him to the test. After asking around, he discovers the master is living and teaching nearby, so the young man goes to see him and manages to obtain an audience with him. He defiantly walks before the teacher, and before he can catch himself, blurts out a challenge: “Show me God! Prove to me that he exists!”

The saintly master calmly extends his hand and, in a soothing, inviting tone, says, “Come with me.” The young person takes the teacher’s hand, in the Asian sign of friendship, and off they go to the neighborhood lake. As they reach the place, the teacher leads the man into the water and tells him to dive in. Then the master does something even stranger. He holds the mans head under the water. As the minutes pass, the man tries three times to come up, but the Lama holds his head firmly submerged. Finally, on his fourth attempt, the teacher lets him out of the water. The poor soul bursts out of the water, gasping for air. “What are you trying to do, kill me?” he yells at the saint. The holy man looks at him with infinite compassion and lovingly, patiently responds: “Forgive me if I caused you undue anxiety, but when your desire for God is as desperate as your desire for air, for your very breath, then you will find the source for Creation!”

This powerful story dramatically illustrates the importance of commitment in the spiritual life. No genuine progress is possible without it. Such a commitment expresses itself in the discipline of regular, daily spiritual practice that paves the way for breakthroughs, for the miracles of grace to happen.

Spiritual practice is the core of our transformation, and it requires what can be called the contemplative attitude, a disposition to life of mystical depth. Spiritual practice often means meditation and other forms of inner exploration. It can also mean prayer. Silence and solitude – the seeking of illumination and wisdom – are further parts of the contemplative experience, a process of our ultimate evolution, our unfolding to higher states of awareness. To understand how this process can unfold in our lives, we need to explore its elements.

This is what I hope we are doing here at OEB. Our personal experiences provides us an opportunity to gain knowledge. Application of knowledge, when done in the spirit of right intent, is wisdom. We live in a mutual causal world. Everything happens as an effect of another action. Either human or not. It started at the moment our Universe was created. We are here as a result of that original event. Everything we think or do is a continuation of that action. Even our deaths contribute to this Universal expression. It is up to us to discover the contemplative dimension of life and experience what it means to be human on a mission to understand the unity of all things.

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Pursuit Of “The Good” Is Another Illusion

By: David Xi-Ken Astor, Sensei

Goodness is a noble quest, but the pursuit of good is another form of living an illusory life. We must be wise in our understanding of the ethical reality in the meaning of the Three Pure Precepts and how we connect with others. If an individual wishes for others what is good for themselves without really knowing what that good is, then the potential for doing harm is real. We know in principle that happiness can not be found in hedonism or utilitarianism (the profit motive). A life pursuing pleasure, ambitious self-centered interests alone, or riches results in a kind of intolerable servitude where what we seek will be always out of our grasp. This type of life-path is always about trying to find ways of surviving in the future and may be incapable of living in the moment. The Buddha would say that a life only motivated by profit and pleasure is unworthy of one walking the Path.

Yet we need to be careful in thinking that a heroic, virtuous, and self-sacrificing life is an ideal one. Considering a life based on “being good” can be fraught with ambiguities surrounding the notion of what is good. What one considers good can be making another value statement. History teaches us that the goodness of the good and the nobility of the great may contain the hidden seeds of ruin. What is interesting about a Buddhist practice of perfecting doing good is that it often reflects that same ambiguities as the hedonist or even the utilitarian. Why? Because working to achieve doing good as an object is engaging in a self-conscious and intentional pursuit to do good in a belief that one’s actions are right and therefore will achieve happiness. This way of social engagement is putting happiness and the notion of what is good as something to be attained, and thus places them outside selfless action and into the world of object, as though good was a commodity. This results in a life-dilemma between one not yet in possession of what they seek as good, and the future in which one things they will have what is desired in order to counter unsatisfactoriness. This dilemma is about how an individual interprets what is right or wrong, as opposed to the notion of right and wrong held by others.

We can find resolution of this dilemma in our practice by not debating with ourselves on what is happiness or unhappiness by trying to find what “should be done”. Doing good should never be debated if we also have an adequate understanding of the situation and not try to over-think the karmic consequences. We can never know for sure how any good action will work out in our mutual-causal world. The more we seek doing good from the perspective of desired consequences, we enter into the weeds of over analyzing the nature of the importance of just trying not to do harm.

An awakened Buddhist practice recognizes that our body-mind is ready to do good as an expression from our Buddha natures. Instead of self conscious cultivation of what is good, we grow quietly in the humility of a simple, ordinary life, and this way is trusting that our actions come from a cultivated body-mind rather than seeing it as the fruit of our efforts. This is a practice not intent upon results and is not concerned with consciously laid plans or deliberately organized endeavors. It is a life awakened to how each moment is and how we are reflected in it. It is about learning to find the harmony in each moment, and between the elements we meet in those moments. If one is in harmony in the moment, happiness and goodness will make itself clear when the time comes to act, for then one will act not according to the human and self-conscious mode of deliberation, but according to the awakened social-self that is the source of goodness. The other way of acting is conscious striving, even though it may claim to be a way of virtue, is fundamentally a way of self aggrandizement and pride, and will be in conflict with the path away from suffering. This is not an easy lesson to comprehend, as it takes time to realize how to act from a deeper place cultivated from our silence. Thus we sit in silence to cultivate serenity from which compassionate action arises.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Duty: The Selfless Practice

By: David Xi-Ken Astor, Sensei

I can not help but wonder about the simple word “duty” and why we do not hear it used so often in our contemporary speech. It almost seems like an eighteen century word used in a more nobler time to refer to action of the highest perfection of human nature. Duty being a responsibility to a higher cause, or to the state perhaps. But I am looking at this word with new light as I also consider the importance of the vows we profess when we step onto the Buddhist path seriously. It almost seems to me that we shy away from considering our practice as a duty rather then a wish fulfilling need. Duty may tug away from our notion of freedom even. If we are working to achieve a state of selfless practice, are we not also, through the power of vows, acknowledging the existence of duty as a force of our obligation to serve others?

What creates the realization of the sense for duty in our practice that transforms itself away from mere obligation? Is our understanding of how to act in our practice not from duty but from expedience reflecting how we think we should act as Buddhists? Is our practice self-serving in some aspects? Those whom their practice binds through conscience rather than by traditional expectations are doing so out of moral authority, and is for them a sense of duty from which the dictates of conscience flows. The power of this dutiful commitment arises out of having made a vow driven by a personal obligation to discharge our notion of social justice even when it is not commanded by higher authority or religious expectation. The “just person” living their vows does what he should do because it is just, and because justice is essential to the very being of a Buddhist practice. When we come to understand deeply how duty arises from living our vows we come to awaken to the immediate source of the obligation to act in a certain way. These intentional virtuous actions are the highest state of excellence of human nature. No matter what spiritual path you are on. Virtue, a component of duty, alone provides the motivation that allows us to extend an altruistic hand that embraces everyone with equanimity. It is the motivation that recognizes the “social-self”. Without this awareness, we do not have a Buddhist practice.

Plato considered virtue as comprising justice, temperance, courage, and wisdom. But without justice, he considered the other three as having little merit. The foundation for that thought was because justice concerns the relation of man to his neighbor. It is the recognition of the value of interconnectiveness and the dependence we have for the importance of other. You see, when we consider temperance and courage we are isolating these human traits for the well being of the individual. That is why showing justice entails duty which is the obligations to act in a certain way for the welfare of others. If the good of no other individual is involved, it seems to me that a person has no duty to be temperate or courageous, even when he possesses these virtues. This is the lesson associated with understanding how we can be “alone with others”, as Stephen Batchelor describes it. Our taking vows is for the benefit of all others, without whom there would be no reason to practice the bodhisatta ideal. I’m teaching from a Mahayana perspective here. Let’s not forget that I am speaking about duty not to an individual person or belief, but from the moral imperative encompassing ourselves AND others alike; the human condition. Acting from this perspective of duty, our actions consists in the submission of the will to reason and in overcoming contrary inclinations or desires, even our personal preferences.

Duty then challenges us to a life of inquire. If we fail to seek the truth of how the dharma is presented to us as we live our vows, we have no chance to awaken to the nature of our Universal human expression. So to live well is to do our duty through our practice and to set aside all contrary desires and obligations that act as inhibitors to a Buddhist life. We are not Buddhist when we are being other things unaware of our vows. Our Buddhist character must be present in each of the other roles in life we have undertaken: spouse, sibling, child, teacher, business partner, and any of the other roles we come to represent. That is our duty as we live our vows. We should not be conflicted or torn by competing loyalties or obligations which pull us in opposite directions. When our various roles command contrary action, duty is weighed by our conscience. When we come to value the encompassing and corrective lessons woven throughout the elements of the Eightfold Path, and understand the principles of moral and ethical justice reflected in the Four Noble Truths, we will no longer experience the ordeal of conscience from conflicting duties when our ego is at rest. We can always find an honorable path for our actions to follow when our sense of duty becomes second nature.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized